then I suggest you go watch a bloody sitcom where by the end of the episode everything is back to normal again. Having one dimensional characters for 6 seasons without ‘flaws’ is boring and unrealistic - as even vampires like Pam can make mistakes.
at least subconsciously. Sure you can try to argue that “he didn’t do it because they were gay,” but come on; after a while it stops being a coincidence and starts becoming pattern. And as a gay man, it’s hard to like a character who’s terrorizing or killing all the gay guys on the show.